First of all, I'm not going to post swatches or detailed pictures of the palette. Other blogs have done it ad nauseum and much better than I'm able to, so please check out Temptalia's swatches here. That post is very picture-heavy, so don't say I didn't warn you. Here's just one pic so you know what I'm talking about: 16 eyeshadows, two eyeliners and a mini Primer Potion. It was US$54, which may sound expensive, but if you take a look at Temptalia's review, she breaks down the cost of buying each of the items separately. Trust me, this baby is worth every penny.
The selection of colours is great. There are some more neutral colours, as well as bright colours and glitter-infused shadows. All of the shadows are shimmery, apart from one matte: the black colour, Perversion. I've given this palette a really good workout, except for the black eyeliner (Zero) and primer. I'm currently using a mini version of Zero and I have a full-size Primer Potion that I use every day. I also already own Last Call as a standalone eyeshadow and Uzi is in another Urban Decay palette that I have. However, that didn't stop me from buying this palette because there are no dud colours here. There's almost always one mediocre shadow in every palette, but not this one.
So I've played around with the palette a lot to the neglect of my shimmery loose shadows, which I prefer to pressed shadows. However, there's enough colour variety in here that I haven't worn anything else for the last couple of weeks! That's really saying something, since I'm a glitter whore. Some of my favourite colours in the palette include Loaded, Rockstar, Haight and Psychedelic Sister.
I've already got favourite combinations that I've been wearing repeatedly, but I haven't been taking photos. For example, I love Haight on the inner 2/3 of the lid, with Loaded on the outer 1/3, in the crease and on the lower lashline. Or a similar combination with Money and Loaded, or Kush and Loaded (yeah, Loaded rocks). This is a new look for me: it's more subtle and it uses the warmer colours in the palette.
This is Bordello on the inner 2/3 of the lid and lower lashline, Last Call in the crease, Rockstar on the outer 2/3 of the lid and lower lashline, and finally Snatch on the inner tear duct area.
Different angle and lighting to show the awesome shimmer.
The thing I love about Urban Decay eyeshadows is how easily they apply. They're really pigmented, blend really well and are never chalky. It's also really easy to build up the intensity of the colour. The only ones I ever have trouble with are the glitter-based shadows like Uzi, Midnight Cowboy Ride Again and Maui Wowie. However, I only really get fallout if I wear them as a highlight, which is what I do with Uzi. They're otherwise fine when worn on the lid with the Primer Potion as a base. (I know some people put eyeshadow primer from the lashline to the brow, but I'm not a fan: I just keep it on the lid and a little above the crease.)
Now the eyeliners. I really think these are some of the most awesome eyeliners ever made. I even bought a mini eyeliner set, but that's another review. The pencils are soft and easy to apply, plus I've never had them wear away or move where they're not supposed to. They kind of set after you apply them, so they stay put really well. If you're a fan of smudged liner, make sure you do it fast! Ransom, the blue-purple liner, is the most incredible colour. I just love it.
And finally, the eye primer. As I said, I use this every day under all of my eyeshadows (except for my Benefit creaseless cream shadows and Make Up For Ever aqua cream - they don't need it). The bottle is looks cute, but it's a stupid shape and means you waste a lot of product where the wand can't reach. I had to cut open my original bottle and put the remains in a pot, there was so much left behind. I managed to get three months of use out of the remnants. All of that would have gone in the bin if I hadn't cut it open.
As always, no product is perfect, so here's what I don't like about the palette. The packaging. This is sooo big and heavy, there's no way I'd travel with it. If you look at the tray with the products in it, it's quite light and a decent size. However, it's a drawer that slides out of the oversized box. When you open the lid, although the New York cityscape is cute, there's really no point to it. There's so much going on there that the mirror is obscured and therefore useless. The LED lights and also tinted blue, which means that even if you could get to the mirror, it would be difficult to get an accurate idea of what your makeup looks like.
Overall, I love the Book of Shadows. The products in it are fantastic, although I'm resigned to the fact that it will permanently live at home. There's a great variety of colours and finishes to the eyeshadows, and I think the eyeliners and eye primer are second to none. For those who love colour, this is a great buy and you'll definitely get your money's worth. If you're more into neutral shades, try to hunt down a Naked palette (I had no luck - I'm really sad about that, but I'm not quite ready to look on eBay).
P.S. If anyone who counts is reading this, bring Urban Decay back to Australia! Please, please, please, someone stock this awesome brand.